Skip to content

eCommerce CRO Audit: The Process, Checklist and Cost

This is how a CRO specialist audits an online store, in the order the work is done. Use it to run your own audit, or to judge one you are about to pay for.

Free 24-point instant audit.

54

Example report

example-store.com

24 points checked · 9 fail

61

Product page

42

Checkout

58

Trust

49

Mobile

  • No shipping cost before checkoutCheckout
  • Add to cart is below the fold on phonesMobile
  • No reviews near the priceTrust

Seven areas, one report

  • Product pages
  • Checkout
  • Trust signals
  • Mobile
  • Page speed
  • Navigation
  • Email capture

By Mantas Karmaza, CRO specialist at MDigital · Updated

A CRO audit (conversion rate optimization audit) is a structured review of a website that finds where visitors drop out before they buy, and why. It combines analytics data with a page-by-page review of the funnel, then ranks each problem by expected revenue impact and effort, so you fix the biggest leaks first.

What a CRO audit is, and what it is not

A CRO audit answers one question: where does this store lose buyers, and what should you change first? It looks at the path from the first page a visitor lands on to the order confirmation.

Analytics tells you where people leave. The audit explains why they leave. A 70% exit rate on the cart page is a symptom. The cause may be a shipping cost that appears there for the first time.

A CRO audit is not an SEO audit. An SEO audit tries to get more visitors from search. A CRO audit tries to turn more of your current visitors into buyers. The two overlap on page speed and mobile layout, but they ask different questions.

It is also not a redesign. A good audit gives you a ranked list of specific changes. Most of them are small: move a button, show a cost earlier, remove a form field. A redesign throws away what works together with what does not, and you cannot tell which change moved the number.

The CRO audit process, step by step

A real audit starts with data and ends with a ranked plan. The page review sits in the middle. If you start with the page review, you will fix the things you notice, not the things that cost you money.

Step 1: Read the funnel in your analytics

Open Google Analytics 4 (or your platform's reports) and pull the last 30 to 90 days. Write down these numbers:

  • Sessions and orders, so you know your conversion rate. The conversion rate calculator does the math.
  • The share of sessions that view a product, add to cart, start checkout and buy.
  • The same funnel split by device. Mobile usually brings most of the traffic and a lower conversion rate.
  • Your top 10 landing pages and their bounce or engagement rates.

The biggest drop between two steps is where your audit spends most of its time. If 40% of sessions view a product but only 3% add to cart, the product page is the problem. The checkout can wait.

If you use a session recording tool such as Microsoft Clarity or Hotjar, watch 20 recordings of visitors who reached the drop-off step and left. Look for rage clicks, dead clicks and long pauses.

Step 2: Review the pages, stage by stage, on a phone first

Now walk the funnel like a first-time buyer. Use a real phone, or a 390px-wide browser window, before you look at desktop. Write down every point where you hesitate, scroll to look for something, or doubt the store.

Homepage and landing pages. Can a stranger tell in five seconds what you sell and why to buy it here? Check the headline, the first screen on mobile and the path to products.

  • Typical finding: the mobile hero is a lifestyle photo with a vague slogan, and the first product is two screens down.
  • Typical finding: paid ads send traffic to the homepage, not to the product or collection the ad showed.

Collection and category pages. Can shoppers narrow 200 products down to 10 quickly?

  • Typical finding: no filters on mobile, or filters hidden behind an unlabeled icon.
  • Typical finding: product cards show no price, no rating and no sale badge, so shoppers must open each product to compare.

Product pages. This is where most stores lose the most buyers. Check the price, the add-to-cart button, the images, the description and the shipping and returns information.

  • Typical finding: on a 390px screen, the add-to-cart button sits below the fold under a long image gallery.
  • Typical finding: size or variant selection fails without a clear error, so the button looks broken.
  • Typical finding: shipping cost and delivery time appear only at checkout.
  • Typical finding: reviews exist but sit at the bottom of the page, after the related products.

Cart. The cart should confirm the decision, not raise new questions.

  • Typical finding: the cart shows a new cost (shipping, tax or a handling fee) with no explanation.
  • Typical finding: a slide-out cart has no visible checkout button on mobile until you scroll inside it.
  • Typical finding: a discount code field sits at the top, and shoppers leave to search for a code.

Checkout. Baymard Institute's checkout research puts average cart abandonment at about 70%. Extra costs, forced account creation and a long or complex checkout are among the top reasons shoppers give in their surveys.

  • Typical finding: guest checkout exists but the "create account" option looks like the main path.
  • Typical finding: the form asks for fields you do not need, such as company name or a second address line shown by default.
  • Typical finding: no express payment options (Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal, Shop Pay) on mobile.

Post-purchase. Most audits stop at the order. Yours should not, because repeat orders cost less than new ones.

  • Typical finding: the confirmation page is a dead end with no next step.
  • Typical finding: no welcome email or abandoned-cart email fires, or it lands in spam because SPF, DKIM or DMARC is not set up.

Step 3: Check speed, trust and mobile across every stage

Three problems cut across the whole funnel. Check them once per page type.

  • Speed. Test your homepage, one collection page and one product page in Google PageSpeed Insights, on mobile. Deloitte's "Milliseconds Make Millions" study (2020) found that a 0.1-second faster mobile site lifted retail conversions by 8.4%. Large hero images, too many apps and third-party scripts are the usual causes.
  • Trust. Can a shopper find your returns policy, contact details and real reviews without leaving the product page? A store with no address, no phone number and no reviews looks risky, even if it is not.
  • Mobile. Tap targets that are too small, pop-ups that cover the add-to-cart button, and text that needs zoom. Check each page type on a real phone.

Step 4: Score and rank every finding

You will have 20 to 60 findings at this point. Do not fix them in the order you found them. Score them (see the model below) and work from the top.

Step 5: Decide what to test and what to just fix

Not every change needs an A/B test. Fix broken things directly: a button that does not work, a missing shipping cost, a checkout error on one browser. There is nothing to learn from testing a bug.

Test the changes where reasonable people could disagree: a new headline, a different product page layout, a free-shipping threshold. Only test if you have the traffic for it (see the mistakes section).

CRO audit checklist by funnel stage

Use this table as the short version of step 2. For the full list, see our eCommerce CRO checklist.

StageTop checksTypical leak
Homepage / landing pageClear offer in the first mobile screen; path to products; ad message matches the pageVague hero, products two screens down
Collection / categoryFilters and sort on mobile; price and rating on cards; sensible default sortShoppers open every product to compare
Product pagePrice and add-to-cart visible on mobile; variant errors; shipping and returns near the button; reviews near the topAdd-to-cart below the fold; surprise shipping cost later
CartNo new unexplained costs; checkout button visible; low-key discount fieldShoppers leave to hunt for a discount code
CheckoutGuest checkout first; minimum fields; express payments; clear errorsForced account, long form, missing wallet payments
Post-purchaseUseful confirmation page; welcome and abandoned-cart emails reach the inboxEmails land in spam or never send
All pagesMobile speed; trust signals; tap targets; pop-up timingSlow product pages, pop-ups covering the button

How to prioritize CRO audit findings: a simple scoring model

The most common prioritization model is ICE, popularized by Sean Ellis. A similar one, PIE (Potential, Importance, Ease), comes from the agency WiderFunnel. Both work. ICE is easier to start with.

Give each finding a score from 1 to 10 on three questions:

  • Impact: how much revenue could this change move? A product page issue that affects all traffic scores higher than a footer link.
  • Confidence: how sure are you that the change helps? Data from your funnel or recordings raises it. An opinion lowers it.
  • Ease: how fast and cheap is the fix? A text change is a 9. A new checkout is a 2.

Average the three numbers. Work from the highest score down.

Worked example

FindingImpactConfidenceEaseICE score
Shipping cost appears only at checkout; add it under the price on product pages8877.7
Mobile add-to-cart below the fold; shorten the gallery or add a sticky button7766.7
Checkout asks for company name and phone as required fields; make them optional5797.0
Homepage hero "feels dated"; redesign it4333.3

The shipping fix goes first. The checkout field change goes second, even though its impact is lower, because it takes ten minutes. The hero redesign drops to the bottom: it is expensive and nothing in the data points to it.

To put a dollar figure on a finding, use the CRO ROI calculator. For example, a store with 20,000 monthly sessions, a 1.5% conversion rate and a $60 average order makes $18,000 a month. Lift the rate to 1.8% and the same traffic makes $21,600, which is $3,600 more each month.

How much a CRO audit costs and how long it takes

CRO audit services vary a lot in price, by who does the work and how deep it goes. The ranges below are typical market ranges, not quotes.

OptionTypical costTypical turnaroundMakes sense when
DIY with a checklist$0 plus your time1 to 3 days of your timeYou know your store, have little budget and can make changes yourself
Freelance CRO specialistAbout $200 to $1,5001 to 2 weeksYou want an expert opinion on a small or mid-size store without a retainer
CRO agencyAbout $2,000 to $5,000 for a small store and $5,000 to $12,000 for a mid-market store; enterprise audits $12,000+. Retainers usually $2,000 to $15,000+ a month2 to 4 weeksLarge stores with enough traffic for an ongoing testing program
AI audit toolFree to about $50 per auditMinutesYou want a fast, complete first pass, or a repeat check after changes

For the full breakdown, including retainer math and when an agency pays off, read CRO agency vs AI audit tool: what each really costs. If you want to try the DIY route with a time limit, the 30-minute eCommerce CRO audit walks you through it.

What a good CRO audit deliverable looks like

Use this list to judge any audit, from an agency, a freelancer or us. A good deliverable has:

  • Evidence for each finding. A screenshot of the real page, the device it was seen on, and the data or principle behind it.
  • A specific fix. "Improve trust" is not a fix. "Add the returns window and a link to the policy under the add-to-cart button" is.
  • A priority order. A ranked list with impact and effort, not 80 findings of equal weight.
  • Mobile and desktop findings marked separately. The same page often has different problems on each.
  • Instructions that fit your platform. A Shopify fix and a WooCommerce fix are not the same work.
  • A baseline. Your current conversion rate and funnel numbers, so you can measure the result after the fixes.

If an audit is a 40-page PDF of general best practices with your logo on the cover, it is a template. Ask for the evidence behind each point.

Common CRO audit mistakes

A/B testing with too little traffic

Testing is the right tool only when you have enough visitors. At a 2% conversion rate, a test that detects a 10% relative lift needs about 80,700 visitors per variant at standard settings (95% confidence, 80% power). Most small stores never reach that in a reasonable time.

Check your numbers in the A/B test sample size calculator before you start. If the test would take three months, fix the clear problems directly and compare before and after.

Fixing opinions instead of evidence

"I don't like the font" is not a finding. Every item on your list should point to a funnel drop, a recording, a usability principle or a broken element. If you cannot say why it costs sales, give it a low confidence score.

Reviewing on desktop only

Many store owners build and check their store on a laptop. Their customers buy on phones. Do the full review on mobile first, then check desktop for the differences.

Auditing once and never again

Apps, theme updates and new products change your pages every month. Run a full audit after any redesign or platform change, and a quick check every quarter.

Where AuditYourStore fits

AuditYourStore automates the page-review part of this process. The free CRO audit checks 24 essential conversion points on your store in under 2 minutes, with no sign-up required. You get an overall score, a grade and a short summary of what failed.

The full audit checks 277 points for $14.95. It uses screenshots of your real pages on desktop and mobile, adds AI analysis, and gives step-by-step fix instructions for your platform, revenue impact estimates and a PDF report. It usually finishes in 3 to 4 minutes. If you connect Google Analytics 4 or Microsoft Clarity, it also reads your own behavior data. See all options on the pricing page.

What AI does well: it checks hundreds of points the same way every time, on every page type, and it does not skip the boring ones. What still needs a human: talking to your customers, knowing your margins and your brand, and deciding which tests are worth your traffic. Use the AI audit as the first pass, then spend your own time on the decisions.

For platform-specific detail, see the Shopify CRO audit and WooCommerce CRO audit guides, and the free CRO calculators for the numbers. To compare your rate with other stores, read Shopify conversion rate benchmarks for 2026.

Frequently asked questions

How long does a CRO audit take?
A DIY audit takes 1 to 3 days of your time. A freelancer typically needs 1 to 2 weeks and an agency 2 to 4 weeks. An AI tool takes minutes: our free 24-point audit finishes in under 2 minutes and the full 277-point audit in about 3 to 4 minutes.
How much does a CRO audit cost?
Typical market ranges: about $200 to $1,500 from a freelancer and about $2,000 to $12,000 from an agency, more for enterprise stores. AI tools run from free to about $50. AuditYourStore's free audit costs $0 and the full 277-point audit costs $14.95.
What is the difference between a CRO audit and an SEO audit?
An SEO audit looks for ways to get more visitors from search engines. A CRO audit looks for ways to turn the visitors you already have into buyers. They overlap on speed and mobile layout, but you need both.
What is a website conversion audit?
It is another name for a CRO audit: a review of your site's pages and funnel data to find where visitors drop out before they buy, and what to change. For online stores it is also called an ecommerce conversion audit.
Is a conversion rate optimisation audit something different?
No. Conversion rate optimisation audit is the UK spelling of the same thing. The process, checklist and deliverable are identical.
How often should I do a CRO audit?
Do a full audit once, then after every redesign, theme change or platform migration. Between those, a quick check every quarter catches problems that new apps, products and promotions add.
Do I need a lot of traffic for a CRO audit?
No. An audit finds problems on your pages, and that works at any traffic level. You need a lot of traffic only to A/B test the fixes. With low traffic, fix the clear problems directly and compare results before and after.
What should a CRO audit include?
Your funnel numbers, a review of each stage on mobile and desktop, evidence and a screenshot for each finding, a specific fix for each one, and a ranked priority list by impact and effort.

See what your store is missing

The free audit checks 24 conversion points on your real store pages and shows which ones fail.

Free 24-point instant audit.